The Bruce Arena Supporters' Shield is the trophy awarded to the regular season CPL champion. The winner of the Shield automatically receives the #1 seed in the Continental Cup.
| Season | Winning Team | Record (W-L-D) | Points | Runner-Up | Record (W-L-D) | Points |
| 1 | Edmonton City AC | 19-9-14 | 71 | Flower City SC | 18-12-12 | 66 |
See also[]
 Continental Premier League
| ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Teams | 
|
 AC Phoenix  Bayern Baltimore  CA Real San Diego  Crossroads FC Edmonton City AC  FC Battalion  Flower City SC Las Vegas United FC  Providence Hope FC  Tampa Bay Mutiny (Defunct)
| ||
| Expansion | TBD | |||
| Championships | Lamar Hunt Continental Cup - Bruce Arena Supporters' Shield - AT&T All-Star Game | |||
| Awards | CPL Golden Boot - CPL Goalkeeper of the Year | |||
| Rivalries | Canadian Challenge Cup - Clipper Cup - Heritage Classic - I-95 Invitational - Tri-State Cup | |||
| Seasons | Season 1 | |||
| Etc | Service Week | |||